Diana Barrett is the only person I’ve ever heard compare philanthropy to bowling.
“You’re picking up that ball,” said Barrett, “and you can’t see what you’re hitting because you’re wearing a blindfold. So you kind of go voooomp! Did I hit anything?! You can’t improve it because there’s no learning curve. That’s what philanthropy is like.”
Having talked with Hal Ornstein who only just founded his own family foundation this past summer, I wanted hear from an experienced grant-maker: someone who could talk with me about the realities, and perhaps the pitfalls, of giving away lots of money.
“It really is difficult,” she said, “People laugh about that and say, ‘I’d like to have that problem.’”
These days Barrett runs a very successful foundation called The Fledgling Fund. It gives money to filmmakers who are making socially impactful documentaries, and then helps builds outreach campaigns around those films. She founded the fund in 2005. Four of her grantees have won Emmy awards and four others have won Oscars, including the makers of “Born Into Brothels,” a film about the children of Calcutta prostitutes.
The wealth that capitalized Fledgling was originally created by Barrett’s father, Joseph King, who has been called a pioneer in investment banking. Upon King’s death, his widow Gioconda King was advised to set up a foundation for tax reasons. The Gioconda and Joseph H. King Foundation was to aid immigrant populations in New York, and Barrett ran it -- or rather, she tried to.
“I thought it would be a way of bringing us together,” said Barrett, “Didn’t work. Every time I brought something up she had no interest whatsoever. To a certain extent, it exacerbated problems that we already had.”
This was the first of many lessons Barrett learned about philanthropy: family foundations are only as healthy as the family is.
“A lot of people have found that their family foundations are just being split into pieces because they can’t get along with their siblings,” she said, “I mean one sibling is really interested in saving wolves and the next one doesn’t care about wolves but he cares about whales. That’s a whole other market. Wolves and whales don’t run in the same market.”
Be it wolves or whales, Barrett says many of her philanthropic peers neglect to do their due diligence before they begin throwing money at their cause of choice.
“The big thing in philanthropy is that people say ‘find your passion,’ when you start a foundation,” said Barrett rolling her eyes. “Passions need to be educated. You’ve got to figure out what this passion is all about. Who’s in the field? You have to bury your ego. Very often I see people starting foundations thinking that the sun kind of sets on their head.”
Perhaps the most surprising reality: according to Barrett, grantees might seek to impress their benefactors by saying a program is going great when it isn’t.
“There are all sorts of issues that come into play that nobody tells you about,” she said, “Firstly there’s the power relationship. You have money. They don’t. There is no incentive for people to tell you the truth about what’s happening in an organization. No incentive to tell you that they used the money wisely. No incentive to tell you that they tried something and it failed.”
That’s the sort of information you need if you really want to make a difference, she said. To return to her bowling analogy, if you’re not getting the right feedback, or any feedback, about your philanthropic efforts, you might end up with nothing but gutter-balls.
Poly Implant Prothese was once among the world's leaders in supplying implants. But after its product was found to have a high rupture rate, a public health scare followed. Its founder was sentenced to four years in prison for fraud.
South Africans paused Tuesday to bid farewell to the country's first black president, but there was nothing somber about it. They sang and shouted and ululated, with some making themselves hoarse even before a memorial service at the country's biggest stadium.
This week marks the start of Computer Science Education Week, and part of that is a campaign called an "Hour of Code," where everyone from President Obama to Angela Bassett is urging kids to try computer coding for just an hour. Some in the tech world say it's about time.
After all, they say, to be a savvy consumer of technology, you have to understand how it works. That means knowing how to write programming code, says Douglas Rushkoff, an author and digital literacy advocate.
"In a course where kids are learning critical thinking and critical studies, they can be looking at and analyzing the biases of different media like websites, like social networks," he says.
Rushkoff says knowing how to build websites and applications will help kids understand that Facebook, for instance, isn't about making friends, but about data mining. He says it's important to know how digital programs work from the ground up.
Dan Hoffman, who teaches education at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, says some fear more computer education means less time for curriculum staples like english and science.
"There's always a battle being an educator as there's kind of that 'one more thing' phenomenon," he says. That is, another thing stacked onto an already full curriculum plate.
But he says if that one more thing is tech instruction, most teachers are all about it. So this semester he's teaching a brand new course: "Computer Programming in the K-8 Classroom."
Reed Holway served in Iraq, where he developed PTSD. His symptoms worsened back in the U.S. He got in trouble and ultimately received a bad-conduct discharge. Now Holway is stuck: He can't get medical care from the VA for the disorder that he says caused him to get kicked out of the Army in the first place.
BP is challenging hundreds of millions of dollars in claims that were filed after the 2010 oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, saying some have no connection to the spill. But legal experts say the claims don't have to be spill-related and BP is relying on a friendly court to limit how much it will pay.
Women hold only about 17 percent of the seats on boards of directors of Fortune 500 companies, and they have an even smaller percentage of senior executive positions, according to a new study.
SABC, South Africa's public broadcaster, live streamed its coverage of Nelson Mandela's memorial service in Johannesburg.
With a mix of joyful, mournful and soulful music tens of thousands of South Africans and dozens of world leaders gathered in a huge soccer stadium to celebrate the country's emancipator. Nelson Mandela was remembered as an "incomparable force of leadership."
Coverage of the memorial service for Nelson Mandela in Johannesburg includes part of President Obama's speech.
Federal regulators on Tuesday unveil and vote on a final version of the so-called Volcker Rule. It's part of the Dodd-Frank regulatory overhaul and prohibits banks from trading stocks, bonds and derivatives for their own accounts. Defining what the rule covers has taken years of work.
Student activism is now at the heart of dissent against the state. But like Egypt itself, the movement is divided. Secular and Islamist protesters are closing down their campuses and demanding that the police be tried for their crimes.
Many Americans who live in rental properties can't keep up with the cost of higher and higher rents, according to a new study by Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies. The report finds that half of U.S. renters spend more than 30 percent of their income on rent. David Greene speaks with Chris Herbert, one of the report's authors, about why there isn't more affordable housing.
Eighteen current and former Los Angeles sheriff's deputies are facing federal charges, accused of civil rights violations and obstruction of justice. The indictments are part of an ongoing FBI probe into allegations of widespread abuse against inmates at county jails.
Under the agreement, Jordan would build a desalination plant and a pipeline would be built from the Gulf of Aqaba to the Dead Sea.
But Republicans blocked a measure that would have strengthened the restrictions on the firearms that can skirt airport detectors.
With stern and often complex limits on accepting gifts, the House Ethics Committee sends out a guidance memo each holiday season. This year's version has seven pages of Capitol Hill holiday gift rules — and one page of advice in the form of a poem.
If the Obama administration winds up losing a Supreme Court case challenging President Obama's recess appointments, the Senate back story could make the win especially gratifying for Republicans.
The track record of products designed for digital privacy has been abysmal — at least until recently. Snapchat, wildly popular among teens, is changing assumptions about young people's desire for digital privacy. But it's not clear whether the trend will stick.
Merrill Newman says his interest in the Korean War may have been misinterpreted by authorities.